Maléna is an Italian romantic drama film released last October 27, 2000 under the direction of Giuseppe Tornatore starring Monica Bellucci and Giuseppe Sulfaro. With a running time of 109 minutes, this Italian movie manages to reveal so much with so little time such as giving one a sense about fascist Italy, World War II, coming of age and a woman's struggle to overcome false accusations, rumors, and jealousy to make a truthful life for herself notwithstanding immense hardship.
The film is set in Sicily during the outbreak of World War II in 1940 when Italy happens to enter the war. Renato Amoroso, a 12 year-old boy, narrates the story in his point view. It all started with his sick obsession to Malena Scordia. Malena Scordia is a daughter of an almost deaf professor and is married to Nino Scordia who needed to leave her to serve in the military. Renato witnesses her life of grief. Almost, if not all, of the women in their town are evidently jealous of her remarkable beauty. False rumors spread like virus and make the townspeople believe the worst about her. Someone tells her about her husband’s death. This loss brings to her great torment. But what breaks her even more is when her father, whom she visits every day, disowned her because he received a slanderous letter about her sexual morals. Not long enough, his father died because of the war’s bombing. Malena falls on so much hard times that eventually left her with no more money. Her poverty drives her to yield to the false rumors of the townspeople and she becomes a prostitute. Renato keeps on stalking her and tries to protect her from all of the people who speaks and does evil to her. When Renato sees her in the company of two German officers and behaved like a mad prostitute, he fainted. His mother believes that he was possessed by demons and takes him to church for exorcism. However, his father understands his son is suffering from sexual hunger. He brings Renato in a brothel; Renato has sexual intercourse with a prostitute whom he sees as Malena. The war ends. The women of the village gather and publicly beat and humiliate Malena. Malena then, leaves for Messina. Not long after her departure, Nino Scordia returns to the town. He is stunned and depressed for no one answers his questions about the whereabouts of his wife. Renato, who knows everything, throws him a letter for he believes he lacks courage to tell Nino personally what happened to Malena. Nino follows her to Messina. After a year, the whole town is great disbelief of their return. But the townspeople, especially the women, are in awe of her courage and start to talk to her with respect. This might also be probably because Malena, though still beautiful, is starting to age and she’s not more of a threat to the women of her village anymore. And at the end of the story, Renato helps her pick up the oranges that she dropped and rides off on his bicycle. He looks at her while she walks away with the thought that he will never forget Malena, forever. And at the end, there is no clue left for the viewers to know whether Malena knew about Renato’s feelings for her or not. This kind of ending is commendable for it deleted the thought of an overrated romantic film.
With such character-driven story, it is evident that the conveyed theme is love. Specifically, two kinds of love which are love for the opposite sex (Renato to Malena and Malena to Nino) and love for family (Malena to her father). The director depicts such theme in different ways. Renato’s love to Malena was lustful, obsessive and possessive. Malena’s love to Nino was passionate, loyal and true. Malena’s love to her father was selfless and full of devotion. Technically speaking, its cinematography is praiseworthy because the setting is visually flawless and the camera angles used by the director works for every scene. Also, its musically adds a perfect touch.
What make the story more amusing are the symbolisms it possesses. First, the scene by which the children were looking intensely to an ant which they tried to burn under the heat of the sun through a magnifying glass. The ant symbolized Malena and child holding the magnifying glass are the women that mocked and humiliated her while the other children are the townspeople who did nothing but watch. Next, the length of the pants of the boys symbolized their manhood. Little boys wore shorts and men wore long pants. Also, the song that Renato heard from stalking Malena symbolized his sick obsession. He comes to that point of buying an original musical disc that plays that song. And the disc symbolized Malena. In the latter part, he threw the disc which tells the viewers that he lets go of his love for Malena.
Looking at the movie through the Feminist lens, the movie tried to present how women of that period were so engrossed with the thought of beauty that results to insecurities and jealousy. This is because women are subject to selfishness and fear of loss. This remains true today, especially in the Philippines where crab mentality is a never-ending logic. I commend the movie for the part of showing how hard and complicated it is to become a woman. However, I resent the part of how it stereotyped women as helpless fragile creatures that needs a knight in shining armor for salvation.
The movie also helped me understand how people that experience great emotional dexterity resort to desperate means. If I was boxed in to the situation Malena, it’s normal to think that there is no other choice left except accepting the label that the society gives to me and use it to my advantage. Malena could’ve also been sick of getting painful treatment out of false accusations and this triggered her to become of what they think of her.
However, using the Marxist lens, the story deemed ironic for me. People who possess the beauty of Malena are rarely treated that way, even by women. The likes of Malena, before she got to be a prostitute, are respected and admired because of the undeniable fact that the society today openly accepts those who are classified as physically beautiful people. However, it is true that other people will pull the likes of Malena down.
As regards to Renato, the movie transcends the usual level of depicting the youth in their puberty. Though somehow true, but it became a little too unrealistic. Personally, I don’t think that a 12 year-old boy would bother stalking a woman to that extent. Also, the part wherein his father brought him to a brothel bothered me. Fathers are liable to the healthy growth of their sons but that was a little overboard. But the movie is Italian and we differ in norms and culture. I respect but detest such kind of parenting.